Vatican official slams breakaway traditionalist Catholics for anti-Semitic positions


“The Jews are our older brothers,” said Cardinal Kurt Koch, president of the Vatican Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, reiterating the terminology first used by the late Pope John Paul II during his landmark visit to Rome’s main synagogue in 1986.

St. Louis Ballet ad

“We are inseparably linked with the Jews,” Koch said.

He stressed that this was the “clear vision” laid down in the Nostra Aetate document issued by the Second Vatican Council in 1965, saying there was “no doubt that in the Catholic Church this declaration is still valid today.”

Koch made his remarks in an interview Tuesday with the Italian religious news agency SIR.

Each year, the church in Italy marks Jan. 17 as its “Day of Judaism,” with a series of meetings and study programs aimed at fostering Catholic-Jewish dialogue.

In the interview, Koch sharply criticized followers of the renegade Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X for rejecting the Vatican II policy on Jews. It is only that small group, he said, who “do not accept ecumenical dialogue, relations with Jews and religious freedom.”

He questioned whether, because of this, they could even be considered Catholic. “These are central points of the teaching of the Holy Father, and if [there is] a group that does not accept a council and does not accept a teaching, one must ask how they see each other as Catholic. This is the fundamental problem.” He added: “Any form of anti-Semitism is a non-Christian act, and the Catholic Church must fight with all its might against this phenomenon.” He said there was “absolutely” no risk that the Church could step back from the position. 

Help us tell the Jewish story with reporting from around the world. Please donate to JTA.

Click to write a letter to the editor.