Israeli minister to hear bereaved parents on ex-general’s appointment as top cop

Cnaan Liphshiz

(JTA) — Israel’s public security minister, Gilad Erdan, said he would meet parents of bereaved soldiers who oppose the appointment of Gal Hirsch, a retired general, as police commissioner.

Several bereaved parents protested the appointment of Hirsch — Erdan’s pick to rehabilitate the Israel Police from a string of scandals involving corruption, sexual harassment and alleged racism — citing perceived failures in Hirsch’s performance as brigadier general during the 2006 war in Lebanon against Hezbollah.

“I can’t believe this man even accepted this position,” said Ham Tzemach, whose son, Oz, died in Bint Jbel, Lebanon, after saving the lives of several of his comrades. “He is unfit. He killed my son and now he will lead 30,000 police officers and again be trusted with people’s lives. This is a nightmare,” Tzemach told Army Radio on Thursday.

Erdan defended Hirsch as a capable officer who had been unjustly accused of the failures of his superiors. Erdan and several of the parents leading the protest are scheduled to meet on Friday. Hirsch’s appointment is to be reviewed next week by a government-appointed panel.


Hirsch, who commanded the Israel Defense Force’s northern 91st Division that year, retired months after the war, which a government-appointed commission of inquiry found had been grossly mismanaged. The committee partially blamed him for circumstances surrounding the trigger to the war: Hezbollah’s slaying of eight troops in a cross-border raid.

However, the committee’s chair, Eliyahu Winograd, this year said the findings against Hirsch were unjustified, as he had prepared his units for exactly such a scenario but did not receive the necessary backing from then chief-of-staff Dan Halutz.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at