Brussels can fight Jew-hatred without definition of it, says envoy on anti-Semitism

Cnaan Liphshiz

BRUSSELS (JTA) — The absence of an E.U. definition for hatred of Jews does not compromise efforts to fight the phenomenon, the body’s coordinator on combating anti-Semitism said.

Katharina von Schnurbein, who last year became the first E.U. official to hold the title, defended the European Union’s ability to counter anti-Semitism in an interview with JTA at the Brussels headquarters of Google, where she attended the launch of the Facing Facts online course on hate crimes developed by the group CEJI – A Jewish Contribution to an Inclusive Europe.

Von Schnurbein was referring to the removal in 2013 from the website of the EU’s anti-racism agency of a “working definition” of anti-Semitism that also mentioned the demonization of Israel as an example of that phenomenon. Following the removal, E.U. officials distanced themselves from that text, which pro-Palestinian activists long criticized as dangerous to free speech.

Yet Von Schnurbein said during the launch Monday that, regardless of the working definition’s status and presewnce on E.U. publications, “the important aspect of the non-legally-binding working definition is that it’s applied.”

ADVERTISEMENT
New Mt. Sinai Cemetery advertisement

Queried by JTA on the “working definition’s” removal in 2013, a spokesperson for the E.U. Fundamental Rights Agency said it was never official policy.  “The agency does not need to develop its own definition of anti-Semitism in order to research these issues,” spokesperson Blanca Tapia said.

The Simon Wiesenthal Center reacted to the removal of the text, which pro-Palestinian activists have criticized, by saying the move compromised the credibility of the European Union’s stated desire to fight anti-Semitism.

But earlier this year, the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance – an intergovernmental agency of 31 Western nations – adopted a smiliar definition with references to Israel. Robert Williams, a delegate of the United States, said part of the reason for introducing the definition was to replace the one scrapped by Brussels.

Noting that development, Von Schnurbein added that the Community Security Trust, British Jewry’s main body for fighting anti-Semitism “is applying the definition in their work, the Romanians have started using it in training of judges and prosecutors, the Austrian as well. So it’s been used.”

The seminar whose launch Von Schnurbein attended will begin on January 17. Created by CEJI with support from Google, Facebook and Twitter, the 16-hour seminar will be conducted online to give educators, activists and other professionals tools to identify and combat hate speech, CEJI said.

Sign up for Your Morning Light